Ego ST 1623T vs Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer Comparison

This article examines two of the best commercial string trimmers on the market: The Ego ST 1623T String Trimmer and the Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer.

Read on to learn more about their individual features and performance benefits, so you can make an informed decision when shopping for a professional-grade trimmer. The Ego ST 1623T vs Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer Comparison is given below-

Ego ST 1623T vs Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer Comparison Comparison

Here we compare Ego ST 1623T vs Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer based on following Parameters.

1. Power and Engine

The Ego ST 1623T string trimmer is an efficient and powerful electric cordless trimmer that offers up to 30% more torque than the industry-leading gas trimmer. It has a brushless motor for superior performance, durability and power, and a wide cutting swath of 15-inches.

The variable speed trigger helps adjust the torque output for precise trimming or edging, while the included rapid reload head quickly and easily reloads new line when you need it most.

The Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer is powered by Makita’s Lithium-Ion battery technology, delivering higher power and longer run time than comparable NiCd batteries. It features a large cutting swath of 16 inches and is equipped with an adjustable shaft for easy access to tight spaces.

The multiple speeds allow you to customize your trimming job from slow edging to fast stringing. Additionally its padded loop handle helps reduce fatigue with extended use resulting in maximum user comfort.

2. Usability

Makita XRU15 PT1 vs Ego ST 1623T String Trimmers—which one should you buy? Both string trimmers offer excellent usability for commercial or residential applications, and both come equipped with superior engines for increased power and performance.

The Makita XRU15 boasts a brushless motor that provides 60% more torque and 50% greater runtime than conventional motors, allowing users to get the job done quickly and efficiently. The Ego ST 1623T also has an impressive engine, boasting a 30cc 2-cycle engine that runs on unleaded gasoline for increased life expectancy and less emissions.

When it comes to usability, both trimmers offer easy-to-use controls, featuring twist handles that allow for comfortable operation even after long periods of use. In addition, both models feature adjustable cutting swath diameters up to 17” allowing users to cover larger areas in less time. For anyone looking for top-notch usability from a string trimmer, either of these two popular models is sure to fit the bill nicely.

3. Features

The EGO ST 1623T and the Makita XRU15 PT1 string trimmers are nearly comparable in every other respect. Each of them has a bump-feed head that, when tapped on the ground, lets out more line.

Both may be adjusted for a firmer grip and more comfort during cutting and edging. In addition, both have a robust brushless motor that extends their runtime, boosts their bull power, and boosts their torque.

The Makita XRU15 PT1 boasts a lightweight, ergonomically designed handle that can be adjusted for precise cutting in tight spaces.

The EGO ST 1623T has an enhanced variable speed control dial, allowing users to select the optimal cutting speed for a wide range of tasks. Finally, each trimmer includes a rapid reload head for easily adding extra line.

4. Versatility

If you need a tool to trim your overgrown grass or garden hedges with precision and versatility, go no further than the Ego ST 1623T String Trimmer or the Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer. The features and performance of both the Ego ST 1623T and the Makita are outstanding.

The Ego boasts its superior versatility thanks to its adjustable cutting head, which enables users to control their cutting angle in order to get the perfect finish.

The Makita on the other hand only offers two adjustable modes. This means that users of the Makita will be limited when it comes to angles, which could hinder creativity and make trimming difficult. Its dual-line trimmer head makes it easier than ever before to reach tricky spots without having to resort to manual adjustment or risky methods such as bending down.

The one thing that may give the edge in favor of the Makita is its lightweight build at just 6 lbs while the Ego weighs 8 lbs.

That being said, all things considered, it’s easy to see why serious gardeners would appreciate the extra weight if it guarantees ultimate precision while trimming with comfort and ease of use – something that can’t be found with every other trimmer out there!

Ego ST 1623T vs Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer Pros and Cons

The Pros and Cons are given below-

Pros of Ego ST 1623T String Trimmer:

  • Easy to assemble since it only has eight parts.
  • Lightweight, weighing in at just 10.2 pounds, allowing for easy transport.
  • Powerful 56-volt brushless motor delivers maximum torque and runs quietly even when under load.

Pros of Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer:

  • Quick start design that eliminates the need for a pull cord starter makes getting started effortless.
  •  Designed with a smaller profile that provides more precise trimming in confined areas.
  • Powered by an efficient 21.7cc 2-Stroke engine that produces less noise than gas trimmers and a quieter operator experience.

Cons of Ego ST 1623T String Trimmer:

  • Battery life can be short if multiple thick lines are used in one session, or if used on high power mode.
  • Starts to lack power and efficiency when set to its highest power settings for long periods of time, making heavier tasks challenging to complete.

Cons of Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer:

  •  Lacks adjustable heights, limiting user options on the trimming process on different surface types and densities.
  • Can be more expensive compared to the competition as it needs additional accessories (shoulder strap) for longer-lasting use sessions.

Ego ST 1623T vs Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer: Which is better and why?

The Ego ST 1623T String Trimmer and the Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer are both great options for tackling tough landscaping and gardening jobs. The Ego is slightly more powerful, with a dual line system of .090 inches and a 16 inch cut swath, while the Makita has a single line system of .080 inches and a 12 inch cut swath.

The Makita trimmer has the advantage when it comes to price, fatigue-reduction features, portability, and weight. The Makita has vibration-reduction as well as an ergonomic adjustable handle and weighs just nine pounds. On the other hand, the Ego is heavier at 13 pounds but offers greater power and cutting capacity to quickly get through large projects.

Overall, if you need power and coverage for larger jobs then the Ego ST 1623T String Trimmer is probably your best option; whereas if you are on a tighter budget or in need of an easy-to-use trimmer for smaller jobs then the Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer may be better suited for you.

FAQ

Q1. What is the weight difference between Ego ST 1623T and Makita XRU15 PT1 trimmers?

A1. The Ego ST 1623T is lighter, weighing 6 lbs. 9 oz., while the Makita XRU15 PT1 weighs 8 lbs. 8 oz.

Q2. What is the battery life of Ego ST 1623T and Makita XRU15 PT1?

A2. The Ego ST 1623T comes with a 56V Lithium-Ion Battery and has an above average run time of approximately 45 minutes per charge, while the Makita XRU15 PT1 uses an 18V LXT 4Ah Battery and has an approximate runtime of 25 minutes.

Q3. Does Ego ST 1623T and Makita XRU15 PT1 trimmer come with a warranty?

A3. Yes, both trimmers come with a 5 year limited warranty on the tool, 2 year limited warranty on the battery pack and charger, respectively.

Q4. How does charging time compare between Ego ST 1623T vs Makita XRU15 PT1?

A4: The Ego ST 1623T has a charge time of 30 minutes or less when using the included Rapid Charger™, whereas the Makita XRU15 PT1 has a charge time of 50 minutes or less when used with their Rapid Optimum Charger™ (sold separately).

Q5. What cutting width do Ego ST 1623T and Makita XRU15 PT1 trimmers have?

A5:The Ego ST 1623T boasts an impressive 15” cutting width, while the Makita XRU15 PT1 cuts at 13” wide making it perfect for tight spaces.

I hope you like reading on Ego ST 1623T vs Makita XRU15 PT1 String Trimmer Comparison.

Leave a Comment